Storia Pomegranate 750ml — BULLSHIT
Munch or Dump rates Storia Pomegranate 750ml by storia BULLSHIT — score 0/90.
Sold as '100% Pomegranate Juice' but it's mostly water, more apple than pomegranate, and sweetened with stevia. India's consumer authority actually fined Storia for exactly these claims.
Why this verdict
- 'Pomegranate' juice that's only 4% pomegranate, and has 3x more apple concentrate (12%)
- '100% Fruit Juice' is mostly water plus reconstituted concentrate; CCPA fined Storia over this exact claim
- 'No added sugar' sidesteps the fact that it's sweetened with stevia
- Label admits added 'nature identical flavouring substances' to fake the pomegranate taste
Ingredients (8)
- Water (safe) — Bulking agent that keeps this a low-fat spread; inert.
- Apple Juice Concentrate (12%) (moderate) — Reconstituted concentrate stripped of fiber; it's fast sugar and, tellingly, the actual dominant fruit despite the pomegranate branding.
- Pomegranate Juice Concentrate (4%) (moderate) — The 'hero' fruit at just 4%. Some polyphenols survive concentration, but there's barely any of it here.
- Salt (moderate) — Adds sodium; fine in moderation but the main reason to watch portion size.
- Acidity Regulators (INS331iii Sodium Citrate, INS330 Citric Acid) (moderate) — Industrial acidulants to tune tartness and shelf-stability. Common but a marker of a formulated drink, not fresh juice.
- Stevia (INS960) (moderate) — A high-intensity sweetener added so they can advertise 'no added sugar' while still hitting a sweet taste. It's a sweetener, just not sugar.
- Antioxidant (INS300, ascorbic acid) (safe) — Vitamin C used as a preservative/antioxidant. Harmless, but present for shelf life, not nutrition.
- Nature Identical Flavouring Substances (Pomegranate) (moderate) — Lab-made flavor added to simulate pomegranate because there's only 4% real fruit. Directly undercuts any 'natural' positioning.