Wegmans Unsalted Sweet Cream Butter, 1 lb (4 Sticks) — TREAT

Munch or Dump rates Wegmans Unsalted Sweet Cream Butter, 1 lb (4 Sticks) by Wegmans TREAT — score 43/90.

Two ingredients: churned cream and a mystery 'natural flavoring' — probably starter distillate to keep the flavor consistent batch to batch. That flavoring is the only asterisk on an otherwise honest stick of butter. It's still nearly pure saturated fat, so treat it like the indulgence it is.

Why this verdict

• Genuinely short list — pasteurized cream plus one flavoring, no emulsifiers or preservatives
• 'Natural flavoring' is undisclosed; the purest butters are cream alone, so this is a small honesty gap in a two-ingredient product
• It's ~80% fat and half of that saturated — 100 calories per tablespoon makes this a portion-control food, not a health food
• Unsalted means zero sodium and full control in cooking and baking

Ingredients (2)

• pasteurized cream (moderate) — Churned dairy fat. A whole-food fat with fat-soluble vitamins, but ~50% saturated fat, so calorie- and sat-fat-dense.
• Natural Flavoring (safe) — Undisclosed flavor component, standard in ketchup.

Healthier alternatives

• Kerrygold Pure Irish Salted Butter
• Publix Sweet Cream Salted Butter
• Salted Butter Sticks
• Original Paneer Cheese
• Good & Gather Whole Milk Plain Greek Yogurt